Papa Jay's - Deli Menu – Papa Jay's Jerky

Papa Jay's Deli Menu

Stop by the #1 rated (and only) restaurant in Clifton, Idaho, we'll take care of ya!  Check out the menu board in town for the latest prices, but here's a sampling of what we've got. All meats are seasoned and smoked or cooked locally using Papa Jay's famous mouth-watering recipes.

Roast Beef Sandwiches 

Pepper Popper

Our most popular sandwich! Roast beef, Swiss cheese, guacamole, jalapenos, cream cheese, bacon, tomatoes, lettuce, and our sweet barbecue sauce. 

BBQ Beef & Cheese

Roast Beef drenched in our sweet barbecue sauce with mayo and American cheese.

Sweet Caroline

Roast Beef with our sweet barbecue sauce and coleslaw.

South Western

Roast Beef with Swiss cheese, cooked onions, cooked poblano peppers,ranch, and our sweet barbecue sauce.

Hot Stuff

Roast Beef with pepper jack cheese, horseradish, mayo, our sweet barbecue sauce, and jalapenos.

French Dip

Papa Jay's famous Roast Beef with Aujus for dipping.


Smoked Turkey Sandwiches

Turkey Avocado

Papa Jay's smoked turkey with provolone cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, and a light mustard sauce. 

Turkey Italian

Papa Jay's smoked turkey with Swiss cheese, spinach, tomatoes, cracked pepper mayo, guacamole, and Italian dipping sauce. 


Pulled Pork Sandwiches

BBQ Pork

Papa Jay's pulled pork drenched in our sweet barbecue sauce. Includes a side of potato salad.


Kids Sandwiches

Kid Sized BBQ Beef & Cheese, French Dip, or Pulled Pork



Papa Jay's has a large selection of fountain sodas, Pepsi and Coke products, and novelty drinks including slush puppies and craft sodas.